The Importance of Ethics and Training

Dec 22nd, 2010 | By | Category: Ethics

Perhaps it was too ironic that Sabin Agha’s blog was published by Dawn yesterday. While many of us were distracted by the awful media circus that was going on in Karachi, Sabin Agha was unknowingly proposing the very solution to the problem.

Agha’s blog is about training media professionals on how to cover conflicts – the importance of following safety measures, acting as an truly impartial observer and not developing too-friendly relationships with security agencies, militant groups, and other involved parties, and understanding basic journalistic ethics that will enhance the reliability and credibility of their reporting.

This proposal is certainly needed for those who are covering conflicts, but it should not end there. As yesterday’s incident makes clear, journalists need training in covering traumatic circumstances of all sorts. Because when we pause to reflect, the truth is that Sharmila Farooqui and the reporters at various media houses were probably not intending to do anything wrong. It’s just as likely that – coupled with the pressures of a competitive news industry – they simply didn’t know any better.

Of course, that excuse is only good once.

Journalists as impartial observers?

by Sabin Agha

Despite being based in an urban centre like Karachi, I have covered numerous dangerous events which includes blasts, police encounters, and violent street protests to name a few. But then, journalism is a profession where journalists often confront situations of extreme danger.

Here I quote one of my many personal experiences: the coverage of twin blasts at Karsaz that struck Benazir Bhutto’s home-coming procession in 2007 is one such stark reminder of a heavy price prevailing democracy paid. While it was next to impossible to prevent the Karsaz tragedy due to the mob, most journalists covering the event became a casualty themselves. A cameraman from a local news channel died in the line of duty while many others were wounded. Though the blasts took place in front of our eyes, we were spared by being in a safe position. Foreign media kept its distance and only reached the spot once they deemed it safe. I emerged unscathed, partly because of the one important lesson I learnt throughout my experience as a broadcast journalist: while covering such events, it is always essential to weigh the benefits against the risks. Cover the story, don’t become the story yourself. I do take risks, like most other journalists; however, I avoid taking unnecessary ones.

When covering sensitive or dangerous issues, we definitely run the risk of becoming a casualty. But what is new to this subject is the changing perception of what the role of a journalist is i.e, a gatherer of evidence or an impartial observer? Pakistan is currently fighting several battles, domestic as well as global, and escalation of each battle means a surge in danger for journalists. In a bid to control the media, journalists are now encountering growing pressure from all the “stakeholders”, be it the government, army or militants.

In my opinion, constantly facing serious and often life-threatening challenges have made Pakistani journalists even more committed. Unlike journalists from developed countries, where personal safety training is mandatory, Pakistani journalists with minimum or no opportunities of such training continue performing their duties, especially in the conflict-prone tribal belt. They have to rely solely on field experience to avoid mishaps.

According to the International Press Institute, 12 Pakistani journalists have been killed in 2010. Still, local news organisations and media outlets in Pakistan have not felt the need to train journalists for hostile environment reporting. This means being unaware of basic journalism ethics, which also undermines the quality of reportage. This also means that they are devoid of tactics for “developing sources” as a news gatherer. These journalists wish to be “impartial” but the hostile environment leads to fear and ambiguity, which results in their compulsion to develop a “not-so-professional contact” within security agencies or militant outfits.

The military as well as the militants are “trained, experienced and organised” and know the rules of their game, but the untrained and helpless journalists don’t! Of late, the deadly approach of electronic media of more information, instead of following measures to ensure the safety of reporters, has taken a front seat. Fear for their lives and pressure for more information from their organisation compel reporters to compromise on reportage. And thus, impartial observance is taken over by merely gathering evidence for either side.

In my opinion, training media professionals on how to cover conflicts will enhance their understanding of their role as journalists and will also encourage their independent decision-making abilities. Truth needs to be preserved; otherwise constructive development of press and media in recent times has no meaning at all.

Tags: , , ,

Leave a comment »

  1. […] from: The Importance of Ethics and Training « Pakistan Media Watch This entry was posted in Media and tagged basic-journalism, local-news, means, means-being, […]

  2. Jang Group/GEO TV had played a very dirty role during Mumbai Tragedy in 2008 while relaying a bogus “Investigative Report on Ajmal Kasab” on GEO TV and the same Jang Group particularly Mr Mahmood Sham (Group Editor Daily Jang), Mr Shaheen Sehbai (Group Editor The News International), Mr Kamran Khan (Senior Correspondent Jang/The News and GEO TV) and Mr Rauf Klasra (Senior Correspondent Jang/The News International) played a very dirty role after the murder of US Journlaist Daniel Pearl in Karachi in 2002. This very same Jang Group/GEO TV is now lecturing Pakistanis for Peace with India had itself launched a Vilification Campaign againt PPP and raised doubts on the Patiroitsm and Loyalty of PPP and President Asif Ali Zardari when they tried to formulate a policy on Kerry Lugar Bill, No First Strike, and Dialogues wih India. Now read what Jang and Times of India have jointly been saying and Jang Group/GEO TV/The News International have introduced a permanent link on their websites to promote Pakistan-India Peace.

  3. An electronic media explosion in this country has thrust open the need for presenters and experts, and they both are not easy to find. The number of news channels, and most importantly, the interest that the viewing public seemingly indicates in those mind you, during peak viewing hours is unprecedented and unmatched elsewhere in the world. Almost the top sycophants like Dr. Shahid Masood, Ansar Abbasi, Shaheen Sehbai and Rauf Kalasra like people are leading the goon of sycophants which are giving indispensable loss to national interests.

    Bashing the Govt along with projecting oneself as a peacenik, it is the easiest route to establishing the credentials of intellectual elitism in the overly expressive socio-political environment of Pakistan, facilitated, without doubt, by pervasive media presence. This is a society and a culture intent on putting up a show, and stealing a march on anyone in the vicinity, even if it might entail putting at risk the edifice of the state.

Leave Comment